River Murray shack owners stymied by red gum roadblock

Hundreds of trees in Adelaide’s parklands are set for the chop, but this Mannum couple cannot build their forever home because of just one river red gum.

Share
River Murray shack owners stymied by red gum roadblock
Damien and Paula Littler have been denied permission to rebuild their River Murray shack after being told a river red gum tree in the middle of their block cannot be cut down. Photo: Peri Strathearn.

This story is free to read. Help Murray Bridge News tell more stories like this by subscribing today.

The state government will chop down hundreds of trees for sporting events in Adelaide’s parklands – so why can’t these shack owners remove just one to build their forever home?

When floodwaters receded along the River Murray in 2023, Damien and Paula Littler thought they had made it through one of the worst experiences of their lives.

Their holiday shack at Bolto, near Mannum, had been rendered uninhabitable and needed to be knocked down.

But a bureaucratic nightmare was about to begin.

A government flood recovery program paid for the demolition, and the Littlers started planning to build a new home on their narrow block – just 10 metres wide.

There was just one catch: they would need to remove a large river red gum which stood in the middle of the allotment.

The tree had already been trimmed to accommodate development on a neighbouring block and, in the opinion of an arborist, it would not survive construction of a new shack within its root zone.

While its health was “fair”, it was showing symptoms of decline, multiple branches had already fallen off, and retaining it “would not produce a reasonable development outcome”.

Thirteen other river red gums on the property would not be affected.

The tree's 15-metre root zone spreads beneath much of the block, and neighbouring properties. Image: URPS.

The Littlers received development approval for the shack from the Mid Murray council.

But the Native Vegetation Council refused an application to remove the tree, thwarting their dreams of a full-time move into the river community and impacting the value of their land.

In the eyes of the Native Vegetation Council – an independent government agency – another dwelling design could be accommodated on the much smaller, 80-square-metre footprint of the old shack, so the tree didn’t need to go.

“This has basically taken over my life,” Mr Littler said.

“I’m not motivated to do anything – the tree is just in my head the whole time.”

What infuriated the Littlers the most was the fact that they had chosen to do things by the book, to go through the proper approval process, and their reward had been nothing but debt and frustration.

If another property owner had simply cut down a tree without permission, they speculated, he or she might have got away with it.

Instead, the couple said they had spent at least $20,000 on consultants in their efforts to resolve the deadlock, as well as paying the mortgage for the shack they were still unable to start building.

The cost of construction had increased by about 30 per cent in the years since their shack was designed, too, they said.

Liberal MP Nicola Centofanti has gone in to bat for the Littlers. Photo: Nicola Centofanti MLC/Facebook.

Liberal MP takes family’s fight to parliament

Liberal MP Nicola Centofanti highlighted the Littlers’ situation in state parliament last week.

She urged Climate, Environment and Water Minister Emily Bourke to arrange an in-person site inspection, review the decision to block the development, and provide the family with a clear timeframe for a resolution.

“Damien and Paula Littler have jumped through every hoop put in front of them, but still aren’t being allowed to build their home to replace the one they lost in a flood,” Ms Centofanti told Murray Bridge News.

“How can the (Peter) Malinauskas government fast-track the wholesale destruction of trees in our parklands, but the Littlers can’t remove one to rebuild their family home?

“Minister Emily Bourke should urgently plot a pathway forward for Damien and Paula so their two-year-plus wait to build a home can finally be over.”

Damien and Paula Littler just want a resolution. Photo: Peri Strathearn.

Ms Bourke took a series of questions on notice, and will be required to provide a response to the Legislative Council by December 11.

However, in a letter to the Littlers in August, she suggested that she did not have the power to overrule the Native Vegetation Council.

She could direct the Department for Environment and Water to file an injunction preventing the clearance of native vegetation, but could not order any clearance to go ahead.

Their only recourse would be to file a case in the Environment, Resources and Development Court.

Surely it shouldn’t come to that, the Littlers suggested.

“I just want to see someone take accountability for what’s been going on for the last two and a half years,” Mr Littler said.

“It just seems like everyone’s covering their arses.”

💡
Help Murray Bridge News tell our community’s stories by subscribing or booking an advertisement today.